The silence at the end of the IR meeting
Near the end of a Pre-IPO IR meeting, I see the same scene again and again. The investor leans in and, gently, puts a number on the table.
"We've been through the model, and our view of the valuation is quite a bit below what you mentioned."
The founder's face tightens. The listing is right around the corner, and this price feels like a very stingy verdict on years of hard work. Maybe you have sat through that silence yourself.
It is not unusual. In Pre-IPO rounds, the valuation a company wants and the number investors offer are often far apart. What matters is what you do next.
Many founders repeat their number, only louder. But closing the gap is not about insisting on a higher figure. It is about making the reasoning behind the figure acceptable to investors.
Anyone can say a number. Few companies can answer "why that number?" Here are the four points I keep checking in investment review, told the way I would over coffee.
How the investor is thinking
Before the four points, it helps to peek inside the investor's head. They usually move in this order:
- What are comparable listed companies fetching in the market today?
- What kind of results will this company post by listing?
- How much will the IPO price be discounted, and if the schedule slips, how long is my money tied up?
- So what price today still makes this worth it?
Then, last, they read the terms. That sequence is the backbone of the four checks below. We simply run the investor's math ourselves, in advance.
1. Why these peers
Listed peer multiples are the starting point of the valuation. That also makes the peer page the most attacked slide in any IR deck.
The classic mistake is "they're in the same industry." Pick peers on industry alone and the investor will respond straight away:
"Their business model is different. The margin structure too, and they're much further along in growth."
Without an answer, that peer multiple loses its power at the table. Prepare these instead and the mood changes:
- Why they are comparable: how the business model, customers and margin structure resemble yours
- How they differ: be honest about scale, growth stage and profitability
- How you adjusted for the differences: a discount or a premium, with reasons
Choosing peers is not about making your company look good. It is about building a yardstick the investor can accept. That is why companies that name their own weak spots first tend to earn more trust.
2. What the growth assumptions rest on
Forecasts for the listing year usually assume strong growth. The chart always points up and to the right. Investors know that, so they press hard on where the assumption comes from.
Their yardstick is simple:
- Assumptions tied to verifiable indicators: order backlog, renewal rates, production capacity. Numbers you can see. These carry weight.
- Assumptions resting only on market outlooks: "the market grows X% a year, so we will too." These tend to be discounted.
Put plainly, "the market is growing" and "we capture that growth" are two very different statements. A growing market does not automatically grow your share. A solid backlog means a good part of the revenue is already in sight; high renewal rates show customers stay; real production capacity shows you can actually fulfil the extra orders.
So when you build the growth slide, flip the order: show the verifiable indicators first, then say "which is why this level of growth is achievable." Same numbers, much sturdier look.
3. The discount at listing
This is the one founders miss most often. The IPO price is typically set at a discount to the company's value at listing, and the listing itself may slip.
Investors take both, the discount and the time cost, and work backward to the price they will pay today:
- Estimate the company's value at listing
- Apply the IPO discount
- Allow for a possible delay and the time cost while capital is tied up
- Work back to the price that makes sense now
So an offer that looks stingy to you often adds up perfectly on the investor's side. If you run this calculation first, their offer becomes easier to understand, and you can see where to give and where to hold. Negotiating with the math is a completely different game from negotiating without it.
4. Terms beyond price
The last one is for when the term sheet lands. Refixing clauses, redemption and put rights, and tag-along rights are not the headline price, but in practice they are part of the price.
- Refixing: a mechanism that can adjust the price if conditions are not met
- Redemption and put rights: rights allowing the investor to demand its money back under certain conditions
- Tag-along: the right of an investor to sell alongside a major shareholder on the same terms
A high headline valuation with unfavorable terms can produce a worse outcome. Some founders celebrate the big number, then find themselves in a much weaker position once a clause kicks in.
So don't negotiate number and terms separately. Put them on the table together. That is what makes trades possible: "I'll give on price if we soften this clause."
A hypothetical scene: Mr. Lee's IR meeting
Let me illustrate with a hypothetical case. (This is not a real company. It blends situations I often see, and the numbers are purely illustrative.)
Mr. Lee runs a manufacturing-based technology company preparing to list. He tells the investor, "Our valuation is KRW 100 billion." The investor replies, "We see it around KRW 70 billion."
First attempt. Mr. Lee answers, "Listed companies in our industry are valued higher." The investor says, "Their margins are different and they're far bigger." The conversation goes in circles.
Second attempt. This time he comes prepared:
- Picks three peers and puts where they match and where they differ on a single page
- Ties the growth assumption to order backlog and renewal rates
- Shows a table that builds in the IPO discount and the chance of delay from the estimated listing value
- Concedes a little on price, but asks to soften the refixing clause
Same company, but the conversation has moved from "how much?" to "which assumption is right?" The investor may still hold at KRW 70 billion, or they may meet somewhere in the middle. What changes is that the number goes from something to fight over to something to examine together.
A few frequently asked questions
Q. Can the investor's first number be negotiated? The first number is usually a starting point. But negotiation works by showing reasoning and evidence, not by repeating your own figure. Prepare peers, growth assumptions and the discount calculation and the talk becomes far more concrete.
Q. Isn't a higher valuation always better? Not necessarily. If refixing or redemption and put terms are unfavorable, a high headline valuation can still lead to a worse real outcome. Look at the number and the terms together.
Q. What if the listing is delayed? Investors already price in the possibility of delay. A realistic explanation of your timeline, prepared in advance, helps build trust.
30-second self-check: how sturdy is our valuation story?
- ☐ I can explain why we chose our peers with something more than "same industry"
- ☐ I can state how we differ from the peers and how we adjusted for it
- ☐ Our growth assumptions link to verifiable indicators like backlog, renewal rates or production capacity
- ☐ I have back-calculated "today's price" myself, including the IPO discount and possible delay
- ☐ I weigh refixing, redemption and put rights, and tag-along terms as seriously as price
Two or fewer ticks? Tidy this up before your next investor meeting.
A first step you can take now
The first step is not grand. Back-calculate your own valuation from the investor's seat. One page of peers, one page of growth evidence, one page of listing-discount math. Those three pages alone change the mood of a negotiation.
A valuation is a story. When peers, growth assumptions, discounts and terms fit together, investors accept the number as a starting point for discussion.
Barun Investment reviews valuation logic with you through an investor's eyes, and helps think through the round's structure and term negotiation. Starting with a coffee and the question "how does our number look from the investor's side?" is more than enough.
Considering a transaction? Start with a conversation
Talk to usThese notes are general and are not advice on any specific transaction.




